Amish Peanut Butter Spread Recipe

A can of peanut butter.

The Amish are known for coming up with delicious one-of-a-kind recipes that you simply won’t find elsewhere. One such recipe, Amish peanut butter spread, is sure to tingle your taste buds and leave you wanting more. 

The Amish peanut butter spread recipe combines creamy peanut butter, light corn syrup, and marshmallow creme to create a smooth, richly flavored spread. This recipe is cherished for its simplicity and delightful taste, offering a perfect balance of sweetness and nuttiness.

Ready to dive deeper into this delectable spread? Our article walks you through every step, from selecting the right ingredients to innovative ways to enjoy your homemade spread. Keep reading to uncover the secrets of making and enjoying this beloved spread in your own kitchen.

Essential Ingredients for Homemade Amish Peanut Butter Spread

The secret to a great Amish peanut butter spread lies in its uncomplicated yet perfect blend of ingredients. You’ll be pleasantly surprised by how everyday kitchen items can create something so delicious.

The magic of the Amish peanut butter spread is in the combination of three essential ingredients. Each brings its unique qualities to the table, resulting in a perfectly balanced spread in flavor and texture.

Now, let’s break down these key components:

1. Light Corn Syrup: This ingredient is crucial for the spread’s smooth and glossy texture. It imparts a mild, sweet flavor that doesn’t overpower the peanut butter, acting as a perfect sweetener and binder.

2. Creamy Peanut Butter: The star of the show, peanut butter, gives the spread its rich and nutty flavor. It’s essential to choose creamy peanut butter for a smooth, easy-to-spread consistency.

3. Marshmallow Creme: Adding a unique twist, marshmallow creme introduces a light and airy texture. It enhances the spread’s spreadability and adds a subtle hint of sweetness that complements the other ingredients.

Creating Your Perfect Peanut Butter Spread: A Step-by-Step Guide

Transforming these basic ingredients into a mouth-watering spread is an enjoyable and straightforward process. Let’s walk through the steps to ensure you achieve that creamy, dreamy consistency.

Instructions on how to make Amish peanut butter.

Step 1: Gather Your Ingredients

You will need creamy peanut butter, light corn syrup, and marshmallow creme. Measure out equal parts of peanut butter and corn syrup, and a proportionate amount of marshmallow creme.

Step 2: Mix Peanut Butter and Corn Syrup

In a large bowl, combine the peanut butter and corn syrup. Use a whisk or an electric hand mixer to blend them together until the mixture is smooth and well-integrated.

Step 3: Incorporate Marshmallow Creme

Add the marshmallow creme to the mixture. Fold it in gently, ensuring that it’s thoroughly mixed without losing its fluffy texture.

Step 4: Adjust to Desired Consistency

If the spread is too thick, add a bit more corn syrup. If it’s too thin, add a bit more peanut butter. Mix thoroughly after each adjustment until you achieve your preferred consistency.

Step 5: Taste and Sweeten (Optional)

Give your spread a taste. If you prefer it sweeter, you can add a little more corn syrup. Remember, it’s easier to add more sweetness than to take it away, so add in small increments.

Step 6: Store for Use

Transfer the spread to an airtight container. It can be stored at room temperature if you’ll be using it soon, or in the refrigerator for longer storage.

Here’s a video to help you understand the process better:

Exciting Variations to Spice Up Your Spread

The traditional Amish peanut butter spread, while delicious on its own, can be a springboard for creative variations. These twists on the classic recipe can cater to different tastes and occasions, giving you the flexibility to experiment and find your favorite version.

A bottle of vanilla extract.

Adding Flair: Vanilla, Butter, and Syrup Variations

In the field of culinary creativity, small changes can make a big impact. The addition of ingredients like vanilla extract, butter, or different types of syrup can transform the basic Amish peanut butter spread into a variety of delightful flavors.

1. Vanilla Extract: Adding just a teaspoon of vanilla extract to the spread can infuse it with a rich, aromatic warmth. This subtle addition enhances the overall flavor profile without overpowering the primary taste of the peanut butter.

2. Butter for Richness: Incorporating a tablespoon of butter can significantly enrich the spread’s texture. This addition transforms the spread into a more luxurious, indulgent treat, perfect for those special occasions or when you want an extra touch of richness.

3. Syrup Variations: Experimenting with different syrups like maple or honey instead of corn syrup can alter the sweetness and flavor. Maple syrup adds a woodsy, autumnal sweetness, while honey brings a floral, natural taste, offering new dimensions to the spread.

The Gourmet Twist: Honey and Coffee Edition

Exploring gourmet variations can elevate the humble Amish peanut butter spread to new culinary heights. Ingredients like honey and coffee can introduce complex flavors and textures, perfect for the adventurous palate.

1. Honey Replacement: Replacing corn syrup with honey not only changes the sweetness profile but also adds a more complex flavor. Honey’s natural richness pairs well with the creamy peanut butter, creating a more sophisticated version of the spread.

2. Coffee Addition: Adding a teaspoon of instant coffee to the spread with honey can introduce a subtle, intriguing depth. This combination is ideal for coffee lovers and those who enjoy a hint of bitterness to balance out the sweetness, making it a unique gourmet twist.

Creative Serving Ideas for Amish Peanut Butter Spread

Amish peanut butter spread is versatile, extending its use beyond just a bread spread. Here are some creative ways to incorporate this delightful spread into various meals and snacks.

Peanut butter and jelly sandwich.

1. On Baked Goods: Apart from smearing it on bread or toast, the spread is delightful on warm dinner rolls or as a dip for apple and banana slices. Its creamy texture and sweet flavor complement these carriers beautifully.

2. As a Dessert Topping: The spread can be an excellent topping for ice cream, adding a nutty and sweet twist to your favorite dessert. It melts slightly upon contact with the ice cream, creating a deliciously rich sauce.

3. In Breakfast Dishes: Consider swirling the spread into oatmeal or yogurt for a flavorful start to your day. Its creamy texture and sweet taste enhance these breakfast staples, adding both nutrition and flavor.

4. As a Filling or Addition in Recipes: Use the spread as a filling for crepes and pancakes or add it to smoothies. Its unique flavor and creamy consistency can elevate these dishes, providing a delicious and satisfying culinary experience.

Tips on How to Store the Spread and Its Estimated Shelf Life

Storing your Amish peanut butter spread correctly is key to maintaining its quality. Here are some tips to help you keep it fresh:

1. Cool, Dry Place: Store the spread in a pantry or cupboard that is cool and dry. Avoid areas near heat sources or direct sunlight, as they can affect the spread’s texture and flavor.

2. Airtight Container: Use an airtight container to store the spread. This helps to keep it fresh and prevents it from absorbing other odors or moisture.

3. Shelf Life: Generally, when stored properly in a cool, dry place, the spread can last up to 2 months. If you notice any changes in its texture, color, or smell, it’s safer to discard it.

Here are more recommendations on keeping your Amish peanut butter spread longer:

Refrigeration for Longevity: Keeping the spread in the refrigerator can extend its shelf life up to 6 months. Cold temperatures slow down the degradation process, keeping it fresh for a longer period.

Glass Jars with Tight-Fitting Lids: Glass jars are ideal for storing the spread, especially if they have tight-fitting lids. They prevent air exposure and odor absorption, two factors that can compromise the quality of your spread. Glass is also inert, meaning it won’t react with the ingredients of the spread.

Nutritional Information

Understanding the nutritional content of your homemade Amish peanut butter spread is crucial, particularly if you are health-conscious or monitoring your diet. This rich and tasty spread is composed of ingredients that each contribute to its overall nutritional profile.

Peanut Butter: Peanut butter is a good source of protein and healthy fats, particularly monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats. It also contains vital nutrients like vitamin E, magnesium, and potassium. However, it’s calorie-dense, with about 190 calories and 16 grams of fat per two tablespoons.

Light Corn Syrup: Corn syrup is a type of sugar, primarily glucose. It’s high in calories and carbohydrates, contributing to the spread’s overall sweetness and caloric content. However, it lacks significant vitamins, minerals, or fiber.

Marshmallow Creme: This ingredient is essentially sugar and air, offering little to no nutritional value other than calories from sugars. It contributes to the spread’s smooth texture and sweet flavor but is another source of added sugars.

Combining these ingredients, a typical two-tablespoon serving of Amish peanut butter spread is quite calorie-dense, primarily due to the high-fat content from peanut butter and the high sugar content from corn syrup and marshmallow creme. This makes it a high-energy food, suitable for consumption in moderation, especially for those monitoring their calorie intake or sugar consumption.

For a more balanced nutritional profile, consider using natural peanut butter, which doesn’t contain added sugars or hydrogenated oils. Moderation is key. Enjoy this spread as an occasional treat rather than a daily staple to maintain a balanced diet. Pairing the spread with whole-grain bread, fruits, or vegetables can add fiber and nutrients to your snack or meal.

Cultural Significance

An Amish woman cooking in the kitchen.

Amish peanut butter spread isn’t just a tasty treat; it’s steeped in cultural heritage and tradition. In Amish communities, this spread is more than just an Amish food item; it’s a symbol of hospitality and comfort.

Often found at community gatherings and family meals, it represents the simplicity, sustainability, and wholesomeness valued in Amish culture. Its ease of preparation and storage aligns well with the Amish emphasis on practicality and self-sufficiency.

As noted by Pulitzer prize-nominated journalist Kevin Williams in his blog:

The act of making and sharing Amish church spread is a way for the community to come together and celebrate their shared values and traditions.

There are numerous anecdotes about the spread being used as a special treat for children or as a quick energy booster during long working days. Its popularity in Amish cookbook is a testament to its deliciousness and the joy of sharing simple, homemade foods.

Final Thoughts

Embarking on the journey of making and enjoying Amish peanut butter spread is not only about savoring a delightful treat; it’s about appreciating the simplicity and joy of homemade cooking. This spread, with its rich cultural roots and versatile nature, is more than just a condiment; it’s a small piece of a storied tradition.

Whether you’re a food enthusiast exploring new flavors or someone who values the cultural significance of food, Amish peanut butter spread is sure to bring a unique and comforting experience to your table.


Leave a Reply